A Guide to Disrupting Incumbents

Part I: Commoditizing Your Complements in the Era of Vertical AI

Join the discussion on LinkedIn!

TLDR: In this essay, the Euclid team unpacks a key strategy startups can use to disrupt incumbents: complement commoditization. We cover the 3 main methods and their growing relevancy in the age of Vertical AI. 

1. Three strategies to shift value: Weaken incumbents' market positions by reducing complement prices, switching costs, or direct demand.

2. Avoid backfire risks: Don't commoditize complements key to your own product's lock-in or assume incumbents will not retaliate.

3. Position for value capture: Ensure your product strategically captures the value flow once complements become commoditized.

In 1998, economics professors Hal Varian and Carl Shapiro published Information Rules,1 a magnum opus on the economics of software. Their re-imagination of corporate strategy for the information age set the groundwork for a range of now-ubiquitous concepts like lock-in and network effects. While the work remains as valid as ever, the ongoing evolution of AI—in our view—is changing the game. In this two-part essay, we will dive into one Information Rule that vertical AI businesses going up against powerful market leaders would do well to remember: commoditizing complements.

Today’s essay will introduce the variants of the strategy, case studies of success and failure on each, and our view on heightened applicability in today’s markets, thanks to the rise of both vertical software and LLM-powered products. If you’re a founder or executive aiming to gain leverage and capture market share in the face of an entrenched software ecosystem, today’s essay is for you.

Like many brilliant frameworks in software strategy, complement commoditization was first popularized by Joel Spolsky—the founder of Trello, StackOverflow, and the must-read Joel on Software. Building on primitives from Information Rules, he wrote in 2022: “Smart companies try to commoditize their products’ complements.”2

To read the full piece, head over to The Verticalist on Substack.

Read on Substack