Deus Ex CapEx

Examining the assumptions and incentives behind the economy-wide bet on GPUs

Two years ago, Sequoia’s David Cahn wrote a piece introducing what he called AI’s $200B Problem. His main takeaway was that there was a significant gap between the capital being invested in AI infrastructure and the resulting revenues generated by those investments. He quantified it by estimating the lifetime revenue required to repay the upfront capital expenditures (CapEx) in GPUs, data centers, and supporting infrastructure. At the time, the mismatch totaled roughly $200B. Cahn explains the math and reasoning behind his calculation:

Consider the following: For every $1 spent on a GPU, roughly $1 needs to be spent on energy costs to run the GPU in a data center. So if Nvidia sells $50B in run-rate GPU revenue by the end of the year (a conservative estimate based on analyst forecasts), that implies approximately $100B in data center expenditures. The end user of the GPU—for example, Starbucks, X, Tesla, Github Copilot or a new startup—needs to earn a margin too. Let’s assume they need to earn a 50% margin. This implies that for each year of current GPU CapEx, $200B of lifetime revenue would need to be generated by these GPUs to pay back the upfront capital investment.

Cahn’s framing resonated because it crystallized something many already suspected: capital spending was outpacing monetization. Hyper-scalers and AI-native firms are investing billions in GPUs, expecting their revenues to scale in lockstep with these investments. Since Cahn first published his piece, the AI revenue problem has grown threefold: the $200B figure has become AI’s $600B question, and it’s not stopping there. We extended Cahn’s initial analysis to 2025 and 2026, projecting data center spending points to an AI payback number approaching $1T next year.

For Cahn’s analysis on revenue, he assumed that Google, Microsoft, Apple, and Meta can generate $10 billion annually from new AI-related revenue, plus $5 billion in new AI revenue for each of Oracle, ByteDance, Alibaba, Tencent, X, and Tesla. An analysis from The Information estimated that AI-native companies are currently at a $18.5B run rate. Let’s round up to $20B for simplicity.

Added all together, that’s $90B of new AI-related revenue, generously. So, for 2025, that means there’s a shortfall of roughly $780B in AI revenue that needs to be filled for each year of CapEx at this level. To reiterate, this effectively amounts to a trillion dollars in net-new recurring revenue, as the shortfall is only expected to grow in 2026. It's worth remembering that total global spending on cloud infrastructure and applications is expected to be approximately $500B this year. The good news is that AI revenue is growing at an incredible pace, albeit with uncertainties around retention and a long way to go. The bad news is that the CapEx explosion does not appear to be slowing down.

Renaissance Macro Research analyst estimates suggest that, so far in 2025, AI data center spending has contributed more to GDP growth than all US consumer spending combined—marking a historic first. Another remarkable statistic: spending on data center construction, excluding the cost of all the technology inside the data center, is expected to surpass spending on office building construction this year.

To read the full piece, head over to The Verticalist on Substack.

Read on Substack