Dude, Where's My Moat?

Evaluating long-term defensibility in Vertical AI

Abstract
1. Why Moats Matters
2. Is Speed a Moat in Vertical AI
3. Evaluating Prospective Moats 
4. Framework for Building Defensibility
5. Planning Ahead for Defensibility

To build a category-defining and enduring business, founders need strong defensive moats, which offer defensibility against competitors and clones. This has been the conventional wisdom in venture for decades. Some of the most successful technology businesses have compounding moats, wherein competitive advantage grows with the installed base. Why do moats matter? Because they’re about offense as much as they are defense. We like this description from Abraham Thomas:1

In warfare, moats are what prevent a castle from being stormed. In business, they’re what prevent a company from being overrun by competition, engulfment, or slow decay. Moats help you acquire and retain customers; they help you outperform and undercut rivals; they help you buy low and sell high, move fast and play bigger; they help you win, and keep winning.

Vertical software, in particular, has been a historical beneficiary of moats. We’ve written in the past about the stickiness that comes with dominating an industry ecosystem. These effects don’t always show up in net retention rates: while mid-stage vertical platforms do outperform their horizontal peers, churn compared to horizontal SaaS peers tends to be comparable on average. A more significant indicator of vertical moat potential is long-term revenue persistence—public vertical SaaS businesses are, on average, 6 years older, 30% more profitable, and significantly more likely to be multi-product platforms.2 Dominant companies, such as Autodesk, AppFolio, or Tyler Technologies, have relied on industry-linked moats for decades. Just as notable are the numerous high-retention, low-NPS Vertical SaaS companies that remain today.

Today, the SaaS ecosystem—whether vertical or otherwise—faces a moment of existential doubt. LLMs have made some past moats obsolete. Moreover, AI startups that have experienced rapid early growth will need to find defensibility in a world where capital is flooding into fast followers and AI products have seen “tire-kicking” behavior from buyers (leading to pronounced churn in early consumer & prosumer LLM tooling). Startups and their backers are, reasonably, wondering what it takes to build a defensible business in 2025. While tactics change, we believe the basic sources of a moat will remain unchanged:

To read the full piece, head over to The Verticalist on Substack.

Read on Substack