We Have Met the Enemy and He Is Us

The Mind-Virus of Big Venture has become a Pandemic

Venture capital has long celebrated itself as the business of contrarianism. The best investors prided themselves on spotting what others missed: the non-consensus founder, market, or product. The venture model was designed to harness outlier outcomes — but it relied on individual conviction, not herd behavior, to find them.

Venture contrarianism was borne out of strategic rationality. As in most investment businesses, there is alpha in epistemic arbitrage. Deep knowledge of a business—its target market, operators most likely to succeed in building it, its underlying technologies, the business models that may or may not work to drive adoption—is a powerful advantage. Only, of course, if that knowledge is asymmetric. The most successful founders (and the VCs that back them) are those who see and believe things that others do not and are ultimately proven right. There isn’t much profit to be had in the conviction that the sun will rise tomorrow. As Peter Thiel observes in Zero to One:

The best entrepreneurs know this: every great business is built around a secret that’s hidden from the outside. A great company is a conspiracy to change the world; when you share your secret, the recipient becomes a fellow conspirator.

Today, that ethos feels increasingly distant. The early-stage financing landscape today is flowing into the same handful of themes, founders, and even funds. Valuations are converging upward as the narrative unfolds of winner-take-all markets, where scale is all that matters. More than ever, investors are outsourcing conviction to a handful of signals: Y-Combinator, elite pedigrees, mega-fund co-signs. More than natural acquirers, incumbent technology platforms have their hands on the rudder—with Microsoft, Amazon, and Meta making unprecedented direct investments and talent bids.

The warning signs are flashing bright red that the venture market has never been more consensus-driven. We believe that the consequences of continued concentration will be catastrophic for venture capital and the broader innovation economy.

To read the full piece, head over to The Verticalist on Substack.

Read on Substack