The Dispatcher Problem
Jevon's Paradox & why rising tides won't lift all boats in Vertical AI
The enterprise technology landscape is currently navigating a structural transformation that rivals the shift from on-premise servers to cloud computing. For nearly two decades, the Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) model — predicated on recurring revenue, seat-based licensing, and user engagement as a proxy for value — has served as the bedrock of the technology economy. It created trillions of dollars in market capitalization by enabling human productivity. Today, LLM-era AI — and the consequent rise of agentic workflows — might be dismantling the economic logic that has underpinned SaaS for decades.
The core driver is a rapid decline in the cost of intelligence—at least at a given level of intelligence (as we’ve written, ballooning reasoning complexity has meant token spend continues to grow, even as the cost of a token shrinks). This effect is unlikely to slow down due to fierce competition among well-funded labs (OpenAI, Google, Anthropic, etc.), not to mention major advances in hardware and software efficiency.
As with all economic-technological paradigm shifts, however, the ultimate flow of value remains uncertain. If agents replace traditionally manual services, one might think they would capture the spend that would’ve otherwise gone to the manual services. The scenario playing out, however, more closely models the commoditization of those services. In other words, services people would have paid $100k for just a few years ago will eventually fetch only a fraction of that amount, as agents reduce the cost of delivering them.
The result of cheaper AI is persistent deflationary pressure on Vertical AI offerings, which are predominantly attractive due to the consumer surplus enabled by LLMs. Pulling data out of documents? Answering inbound phone calls? Drafting perfunctory compliance reports? Products like these can be excellent wedges today when infrastructure and know-how are scarce, and adoption is low. Soon, they will be table stakes — as excess margin is competed away by several well-funded, credible, nicely growing startups in every category. Any startup that hasn’t developed a moat in the meantime will be a casualty.
To read the full piece, head over to The Verticalist on Substack.